Saved from the wrecking ball

Tom Papa and Rick Gregory almost had their plans for an old paper mill on Hull Street reduced to rubble.

The partners’ firm, Fountainhead Development, is planning 91 apartments along the James River in the old Caraustar industrial paper mill at 115 Hull St., Papa said Friday. But the pair paid a little more than they wanted.

That’s because Caraustar, which wasn’t aware of Fountainhead’s plans for the property, had put the building under contract for demolition.

“We practically had to throw ourselves in front of the wrecking balls that were already onsite,” Papa said.

With a crew already tearing out the mill’s innards, Fountainhead was left to negotiate with the demolition company to keep it from doing what it was hired to do. Brokerage firm CBRE, which had the building under contract, negotiated a settlement of about $152,000 that was wrapped into closing costs, which totaled about $860,000, Papa said.

Papa said he was excited that Fountainhead was able to save the building that he said has been a part of Richmond’s history for about 150 years.

The deal is so recent that Fountainhead is still working up a cost estimate for the renovation and has yet to secure a lender. But Fountainhead has big plans for the space, including a pool, a movie screening area, a gym, great views of the city and access to hiking trails along the canal.

Papa said Fountainhead was going for an edgier vibe with their apartments that were “more in touch with the building’s industrial past.”

The property is surrounded by a large gravel lot, much of which belongs to the city because of the nearby floodwall, Papa said. But there will also be plenty of space for the pool and parking.

Fountainhead also runs the Commons at Plant Zero and Plant Zero Lofts in the Hull Street area.

The new building will be called South Canal Lofts, Papa said.

View Larger Map

Notify of
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Scott Ukrop
Scott Ukrop
9 years ago

We at the Corrugated Box Building are excited about the continued development and adaptive reuse here in Manchester. Kudos to Rick Gregory and Tom Papa for their additional commitment and investment in the neighborhood. These types of projects and amenities will further propel Richmond as we seek to become the Capital of Creativity.

Garry Marshall
Garry Marshall
9 years ago

You’ve got to be kidding me! I looked at that building for almost two years when I lived in Warehouse 201 and was really looking forward to the day when it was demolished and replaced with a taller, more modern building to take advantage of the views and proximity to the river. That is one of the ugliest buildings in Richmond and full of industrial waste. I can’t imagine it looking decent.

Old Tenant
Old Tenant
9 years ago

Wow. All I have to say is GOOD LUCK to Fountainhead. I am glad they are investing so much into Manchester because the area has such great potential, but they are THE WORST at managing buildings and tenants. Worst rental company I have ever dealt with.