Another Fan bar gets the boot

Another bar in the Fan has been kicked out of its space.

Property managers Bandazian & Holden changed the locks Monday afternoon at Cafe Diem at 600 N. Sheppard St. But Nathan Hughes, a broker with the firm, said it doesn’t have to end like this.

“Cafe Diem still has the opportunity to remedy any kind of default situation,” he said.

Owner Richard Arthur has been in the space about 11 years, Hughes said. Arthur could not be reached by press time.

If Cafe Diem can’t make good on its lease, it will be the second long-running Fan bar to close in two weeks.

Last week, Eck Enterprises evicted Mulligan’s after a 16-year run at its West Main Street location. Mulligan’s owners posted a note on its website saying it was seeing some success with its rebranding effort and that “profitability was in sight.”

“Given a little more time, we are confident that our debts would have been satisfied,” the note read. “However, our landlord is unwilling to allow this time and has locked us out, ending our long-standing business relationship. Obviously, we are more than a little disappointed by their decision.”

The owners are exploring other locations, according to the note.

View Larger Map

Leave a Reply

13 Comments on "Another Fan bar gets the boot"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted

Diners have come to expect more than mediocracy for their hard-earned money. As the quality of food in local restaurants increased, the ones who’ve been skating by on their reputations get left behind.


Technicality, but the Fan District’s Western boundary is the Boulevard… Cafe Diem is located in the Museum District I believe.


you’re obviously not from richmond originally


mortgagemark is correct. The Fan ends at the Boulevard.


You’re right, it is a technicality. BFD, get over yourself. The bottom line is that another local business has shut its doors. Maybe you can go to Chipotle.
BTW, it wasn’t that long ago that the area was called West of Boulevard and before that, the Upper Fan. So technically the Fan ends at Boulevard. I’ve lived in the area for 30+ years and call it the Fan.


Great location, terrible service. The bartender there had the worst attitude.


worst bartenders ever

Hardin Thicke

This is the best news to hit “the devils triangle” since they closed the club ritz and turned it into a pizza place.


Anyone else noticed that the 3 most recently featured places to shut down (or not have their lease renewed) all had bad food and mediocre service? I agree with the poster above, there are too many great restaurants and bars in this city for the places unwilling to adapt to survive. I hate seeing people lose their dreams and jobs, but you can’t be upset that someone is working harder and providing a better service and product.

Jake Crocker

Mulligans was in Uptown (Main is the boundary), hence the name Mulligans Uptown Bar & Grille. Cafe Diem was in The Museum District (Boulevard is the boundary) or even more specifically The Devil’s Triangle.


As a neighbor, I’m pretty happy they will be gone – whatever comes in might actually be good. No loss, no surprise.


I marked the end of Cafe Diem when Piedmont Souprize stopped playing their every Sunday. That was one of the best free shows around, and the crowds absolutely loved it.


That place had the worst service of any airport bar I have ever been to.